Paranormal Investigation - Nancy Eagleson Birthday Celebration

Sat, July 06 2019, 7:00 PM - Sun, July 07 2019, 2:00 AM [EST]

112 South Williams Street, Paulding, Ohio, 45879, United States




1. Select Seats

2. Review and Proceed

Sale ended

Paranormal Investigation - Nancy Eagleson birthday Partial Approval -$75.00

Enter your discount code

  • Subtotal (excluding fees and discounts)
  • Fee
  • Total amount

Event Information

Sat, July 06 2019, 7:00 PM - Sun, July 07 2019, 2:00 AM [EST]

About the Event

Event location is The Old Paulding County Jail, 112 South Williams Street, Paulding, Ohio, 45879

This is a small intimate event. This is a first time for this event, and we believe this will be amazing!

This is 1 of 4 of our Birthday Celebration Events this year! Not only do we want to honor our resident spirit's birthday, but this will also serve as a paranormal experiment, to see if activity is higher and if our ghosts like a birthday party!

Reservations are EXTREAMLY limited and are on a first come first serve basis.

While there are several resident spirits that reside at The Old Paulding Jail, there is one, who communicates with us in the dungeon tunnels and cells in the basement and she is Nancy Eagleson.

Nancy was a beautiful 15 year old girl who was born July 3rd, 1946 and resided in Paulding, Ohio. One fateful night, back on November 13th, 1960, Nancy was abducted while walking home from the movie theater with her little sister. After an extensive search, she was found murdered along a wooded area not far from home. Law enforcement conducted years of investigations, yet her murder case has remained unsolved to this day.

In 2013, the previous owners of The Old Paulding Jail discovered a false wall in the basement. After they opened the wall they discovered the catwalk tunnels and 6 cells that were bricked over as well. They opened the first cell to find what was later believed to be missing evidence (a piece of dress and a shoe) that belonged to Nancy. BCI was on scene for a week after the discovery, yet found nothing more. The items were sent to the crime lab with hopes of obtaining some new information. However, DNA tests came back as inconclusive as the DNA was far too degraded.

Nancy communicates with us on a regular basis and we even have a photograph (pictured on this event) that was obtained in the dungeon cell in the basement where the evidence was found.

We have some theories as to why she is at the jail. Could it be because her evidence was hidden there? Could it be that there is something more to find in the cells that haven't been opened and are still bricked shut? Could it be because she is there looking for help and answers on finding her killer? We are not quite sure as of yet, but we get a bit closer to those answers each year. We hope to one day have the killer revealed to us.

This year marks Nancy's 73rd Birthday, were she still alive today.

We spend a lot of time at The Old Paulding Jail, and quite honestly, we are on very good terms with the Spirits and they are much like family.

This year we want to do something special for Nancy. We want to celebrate her birthday and continue our communication and research into this tragic event that happened to her, by not just dwelling on the sad event that took place, but by also having a small party for her and celebrating her Birthday. We know every child and teenager likes to have a birthday party!

Come Join us for this very amazing and special event. I am sure our resident Spirits will most likely be attending too!

Your Ticket includes:
7:00 pm - Doors open - Meet & Greet the 187 P.I. Team, BBQ Dinner
8:30 pm - Birthday cake for Everyone and celebration ceremony for Nancy
9:15 pm to 2:00 am - Tour of the Jail and Paranormal Investigation with Nancy and friends

There will be drinks and light snacks throughout the night.
Your ticket also allows you to sleep over in Ohio's most haunted Jail! If you choose to sleep over, you will need to bring your own sleeping bag or air mattress, blankets and pillow, much like indoor camping. There are working bathrooms, and electric at the Jail. Departure from the Jail is 11:00 am. if you are sleeping over, or 2:00 am if you are not sleeping over.

This event is not for someone who can not climb stairs. There are no elevators in the Jail and even access to the first floor cell block has a few steps.

 Come join us during this once a year, very special event!

Some of the many, many things that goes on at the Jail include: Lights being turned on / off, footsteps, male and female disembodied voices, people have been touched, opening and closing of doors / cabinets, whistling, jingling of keys, old time music and so much more!

No one under the age of 13 is permitted. Anyone under the age of 18 must be accompanied by an adult.


While the jail is very haunted, we have no control over the resident spirits or any spirits that visit the jail. That being said, we cannot guarantee you will experience any paranormal activity, however we will have all conditions in place for your best possible experience and best possible chance of capturing some paranormal activity.

All reservations must be made online and in advance.
Once your resevation is booked all sales are final. There are no refunds.

Event Location

About the Organizer

Shelly Robertson, founder and lead investigator at 187 P.I. Owner and operator of The Old Paulding Jail.

CONTACT ORGANIZER View other events